News & InsightsNewsletterLegislation Hub

Foresight

Foresight
AboutContactLog in
Book a Demo
Foresight logo
All News & Insights

BASF's REACH Tonnage Downgrade Appeal Succeeds

REACH
28
August 2024
•
450
Dr Steven Brennan
The Board of Appeal found in favour of BASF, concluding that the ECHA had breached its duty to examine each case individually.
Stack of paper on a desk
Quick prompts

AI Generated

Get to the point quicker with prompts - a smarter way to get the information you need from our articles.

Summarise this article

AI Assistant

This feature and much more is available on our platform. If you would like early access, please leave your email and we'll get in touch.

We'll be in touch when the Assistant is ready.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Mountains

The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) Board of Appeal has annulled a critical decision regarding the compliance check of the registration of the substance 1,6-dichlorohexane, filed by BASF SE, a major chemical company based in Germany. The decision, issued on 3 November 2022, required BASF to fulfil certain information requirements under Annex IX of the REACH Regulation. However, the Board of Appeal has now partially overturned this decision, asserting that BASF's downgrade in the tonnage band was not properly considered.

Background to the Dispute

The dispute arose from the ECHA's compliance check of BASF's registration for 1,6-dichlorohexane, a chemical used in various industrial applications. BASF initially registered the substance at a higher tonnage band of 100 to 1,000 tonnes per year. However, in May 2022, BASF downgraded its registration to a lower tonnage band of 10 to 100 tonnes per year, citing a significant reduction in demand from a key customer.

The ECHA, despite acknowledging the tonnage downgrade, proceeded with its compliance check based on the original higher tonnage band. This led to the November 2022 decision, which imposed extensive information requirements on BASF under Annex IX of the REACH Regulation.

Arguments and Proceedings

BASF appealed the decision, arguing that the ECHA failed to properly consider the tonnage downgrade and breached its right to good administration as set out in Article 41 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. BASF contended that the downgrade was a legitimate commercial decision and that the ECHA had wrongly applied the higher tonnage band requirements.

The ECHA, on the other hand, maintained that the tonnage downgrade should not impact the ongoing compliance check, as BASF was still operating at the higher tonnage band in the preceding calendar year. The agency argued that its decision was consistent with the REACH Regulation and that it had followed standard procedures.

Board of Appeal’s Decision

The Board of Appeal found in favour of BASF, concluding that the ECHA had indeed breached its duty to examine each case individually. The Board determined that the ECHA's decision to disregard BASF's tonnage downgrade was unjustified and that the agency had failed to consider other relevant factors, such as the volume of the substance produced in the year following the downgrade and the specific reasons provided by BASF for the downgrade.

The Board emphasized that the ECHA's assessment should not have been limited to the volume produced in the calendar year preceding the downgrade. Instead, a comprehensive evaluation of all relevant circumstances was necessary. As a result, the Board annulled the decision insofar as it required BASF to provide information under Annex IX.

Implications and Next Steps

The annulment of the contested decision has significant implications for BASF and potentially for other companies subject to ECHA compliance checks. The case has been remitted to ECHA for further action, taking into account the Board of Appeal's findings. Additionally, BASF will receive a refund of the appeal fee, as the appeal was decided in its favour.

This ruling underscores the importance of thorough and individualised assessments in compliance checks under the REACH Regulation, particularly when companies adjust their registrations based on legitimate commercial considerations. ECHA will need to refine its procedures to ensure that such factors are fully considered in future compliance checks.

Read the source story

Read this article now for free!

You have read 3 articles.
Create a free account
or
Log in
to finish reading this article now.

Subscribe to our weekly digest

Sign up to receive our newsletter every Tuesday and get access to all of our content.

By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
This is some text inside of a div block.

Trusted by professionals at

Dupont
ECHA - European Chemicals Agency
Energizer
Chemours
This is some text inside of a div block.

Get Foresight Today

Stay compliant, reduce risk, and protect your business with our AI-powered chemical policy monitoring—tailored just for you.

Global monitoring of 1,200+ sources
Expert-reviewed, trusted regulatory alerts
Instant risk identification for 350k+ substances

Ready to supercharge your policy monitoring workflow?

We’ll be in touch soon with more details and support to help you get started.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Share with a friend
Copy link

Related Articles

Chemicals manufacturingEU Scientists Urge REACH Revision to Tackle Chemical Mixture Risks

June 6, 2025

EU ParliamentEU Lawmakers Clash Over PFAS Ban Plans in ENVI Committee Debate

May 16, 2025

Paint coatingsReport Suggests Restrictions on Methylenedianilines Amid Carcinogenic and Environmental Concerns

May 9, 2025

Foresight regulatory experts
Streamline your chemical compliance
Easy-to-use product compliance management for small and mid-sized manufacturers — mitigate risk and protect market access.
Get started
Subscribe to Foresight's newsletter
Stay ahead with the latest news & insights
Join 1,000s of compliance professionals getting the latest insights right to their inbox for free, every Tuesday.
100% free. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Stay ahead with the latest news & insights
Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter covering news, events, and expert insights.

Related articles

Chemicals manufacturing

EU Scientists Urge REACH Revision to Tackle Chemical Mixture Risks

Leading scientists call on the EU to include a Mixture Assessment Factor in REACH, aiming to protect health and ecosystems from combined chemical exposure.

6

Jun 2025

REACH
EU Parliament

EU Lawmakers Clash Over PFAS Ban Plans in ENVI Committee Debate

Debate over PFAS ban intensifies as EU Commission and MEPs discuss REACH reform and industrial exemptions in May ENVI meeting.

16

May 2025

REACH
Paint coatings

Report Suggests Restrictions on Methylenedianilines Amid Carcinogenic and Environmental Concerns

ECHA flags methylenedianilines for potential restrictions in EU due to health and environmental risks; industry urged to monitor developments.

9

May 2025

REACH
Foresight
Providing critical insights, analysis, and guidance to help businesses anticipate changes, make informed decisions, and stay ahead.
News & Insights
Newsletter
Legislation Hub
Coverage
Contact
About
© 2025 Foresight. All rights reserved.
SitemapTerms of servicePrivacy policyCookie policy