
EFSA Seeks Feedback on Overhaul of Weight of Evidence and Biological Relevance Guidance
EFSA launches consultation on updating its Weight of Evidence and Biological Relevance guidance, aiming to streamline chemical risk assessment practices.


The European Commission has proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) 2019/1021 to extend exemptions and adjust limits on perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), its salts, and related compounds in firefighting foams, citing operational challenges in compliance. The Commission opened a public consultation from 8 November to 6 December 2024 to gather feedback on these revisions, which primarily address deadlines and technical limits for PFOA in fire safety applications.
PFOA, classified as a persistent organic pollutant (POP), is heavily restricted in the EU under the Stockholm Convention. However, certain industries have faced challenges meeting the established 2025 phase-out deadline. These challenges include difficulties in detecting PFOA levels in existing firefighting foams and the complex processes involved in replacing foam systems. The draft regulation aims to alleviate these difficulties by extending the deadline for specific PFOA uses to 3 December 2025, the maximum extension allowed under the Convention.
The draft regulation proposes extending the exemption for using PFOA-containing firefighting foams from 4 July 2025 to 3 December 2025. This extension applies to systems already installed to suppress liquid fuel vapours and Class B fires, ensuring adequate time for operators to transition to fluorine-free alternatives without inadvertently switching to other fluorinated options.
Recognising potential PFOA residuals from past applications, the amendment sets a specific UTC limit of 10 mg/kg for PFOA in firefighting foams already in place. This limit will remain effective for three years, granting operators time to implement replacements. Additionally, the regulation proposes the same limit for fluorine-free foams used after cleaning existing systems, mitigating contamination risks from residual PFOA.
The amendment proposes eliminating the requirement for periodic reviews of UTC limits for certain medical devices and transported isolated intermediates. This change aims to streamline regulatory requirements and reflects a lack of new data necessitating further revisions.
This regulation acknowledges operational complexities in replacing PFOA-containing firefighting foams across Europe, especially for industries with substantial inventory and compliance hurdles. By providing a feasible transition period, the Commission anticipates improved adherence to POP regulations, promoting a gradual shift to fluorine-free alternatives rather than temporary PFAS-based substitutes.
Foresight continuously tracks 1000s of sources and maps updates to your portfolio:




EFSA launches consultation on updating its Weight of Evidence and Biological Relevance guidance, aiming to streamline chemical risk assessment practices.

The Netherlands refines its list of potential ZZS chemicals to better align with EU assessments, boosting early detection and regulatory foresight.

Germany's CONMAR-Impact study sets new environmental quality standards for TNT in marine ecosystems, raising industry-wide compliance questions.
Subscribe to Foresight Weekly and get the latest insights on regulatory changes affecting chemical compliance.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
Read by professionals at