News & InsightsNewsletterLegislation Hub

Foresight

Foresight
AboutContactLog in
Book a Demo
Foresight logo
All News & Insights

Grace GmbH Challenges ECHA Over REACH Registration Data Approach

REACH
2
April 2024
•
320
Dr Steven Brennan
The dispute, catalogued as Case A-002-2024, revolves around ECHA's insistence on additional testing for lanthanum chloride, anhydrous.
Grace GmbH logo
Quick prompts

AI Generated

Get to the point quicker with prompts - a smarter way to get the information you need from our articles.

Summarise this article

AI Assistant

This feature and much more is available on our platform. If you would like early access, please leave your email and we'll get in touch.

We'll be in touch when the Assistant is ready.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Mountains

Grace GmbH, a prominent chemical manufacturer from Germany, has initiated a legal challenge against a decision made by the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA). This development introduces a pivotal moment in the realm of regulatory compliance within the European Union's chemicals legislation.

Core of the Dispute

The dispute, catalogued as Case A-002-2024, revolves around ECHA's insistence on additional testing for lanthanum chloride, anhydrous—a substance widely utilized across various industrial sectors. Grace GmbH lodged the appeal with ECHA’s Board of Appeal on 8 February 2024, following the rejection of their proposed alternative testing strategy by the agency in November 2023.

Grace GmbH’s appeal targets the ECHA’s mandate for an exhaustive suite of tests. These include studies on gene mutation, toxicity testing on aquatic and terrestrial organisms, and prenatal developmental toxicity tests, among others. The company had proposed utilizing data from analogous substances through a "read-across" methodology as a substitute for conducting new animal studies.

Argument Base of Grace GmbH

The company argues that its suggested read-across approach adheres to Annex XI of the REACH Regulation, claiming that structural and property similarities between lanthanum chloride and other lanthanum compounds justify the substitution. It underscores that existing data on substances like lanthanum carbonate and acetate sufficiently addresses several of the ECHA’s requirements, thus challenging the necessity for additional testing.

In its appeal, Grace GmbH raises critical legal issues:

  • Manifest Error in Assessment: Alleging that ECHA incorrectly evaluated the proposed read-across adaptation.
  • Breach of Proportionality Principle: Contesting ECHA’s requirement for further studies as disproportionate.
  • Violation of Equal Treatment Principle: Claiming inconsistency in ECHA’s acceptance of similar read-across adaptations in the past.

The firm seeks a partial overturning of the contested decision on specific information requirements and demands a refund of the appeal fee.

Potential Implications and Further Information

This case shines a spotlight on the delicate balance between chemical safety assurance and the adherence to ethical standards in scientific research. The appeal’s outcome may set a precedent for the evaluation and acceptance of read-across adaptations under EU chemical regulations, influencing the compliance strategies of European chemical manufacturers.

Read the source story

Grace GmbH, a prominent chemical manufacturer from Germany, has initiated a legal challenge against a decision made by the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA). This development introduces a pivotal moment in the realm of regulatory compliance within the European Union's chemicals legislation.

Core of the Dispute

Read this article now for free!

You have read 3 articles.
Create a free account
or
Log in
to finish reading this article now.

Subscribe to our weekly digest

Sign up to receive our newsletter every Tuesday and get access to all of our content.

By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
This is some text inside of a div block.

Trusted by professionals at

Dupont
ECHA - European Chemicals Agency
Energizer
Chemours
This is some text inside of a div block.

Get Foresight Today

Stay compliant, reduce risk, and protect your business with our AI-powered chemical policy monitoring—tailored just for you.

Global monitoring of 1,200+ sources
Expert-reviewed, trusted regulatory alerts
Instant risk identification for 350k+ substances

Ready to supercharge your policy monitoring workflow?

We’ll be in touch soon with more details and support to help you get started.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Share with a friend
Copy link

Related Articles

Chemicals manufacturingEU Scientists Urge REACH Revision to Tackle Chemical Mixture Risks

June 6, 2025

EU ParliamentEU Lawmakers Clash Over PFAS Ban Plans in ENVI Committee Debate

May 16, 2025

Paint coatingsReport Suggests Restrictions on Methylenedianilines Amid Carcinogenic and Environmental Concerns

May 9, 2025

Foresight regulatory experts
Streamline your chemical compliance
Easy-to-use product compliance management for small and mid-sized manufacturers — mitigate risk and protect market access.
Get started
Subscribe to Foresight's newsletter
Stay ahead with the latest news & insights
Join 1,000s of compliance professionals getting the latest insights right to their inbox for free, every Tuesday.
100% free. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Stay ahead with the latest news & insights
Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter covering news, events, and expert insights.

Related articles

Chemicals manufacturing

EU Scientists Urge REACH Revision to Tackle Chemical Mixture Risks

Leading scientists call on the EU to include a Mixture Assessment Factor in REACH, aiming to protect health and ecosystems from combined chemical exposure.

6

Jun 2025

REACH
EU Parliament

EU Lawmakers Clash Over PFAS Ban Plans in ENVI Committee Debate

Debate over PFAS ban intensifies as EU Commission and MEPs discuss REACH reform and industrial exemptions in May ENVI meeting.

16

May 2025

REACH
Paint coatings

Report Suggests Restrictions on Methylenedianilines Amid Carcinogenic and Environmental Concerns

ECHA flags methylenedianilines for potential restrictions in EU due to health and environmental risks; industry urged to monitor developments.

9

May 2025

REACH
Foresight
Providing critical insights, analysis, and guidance to help businesses anticipate changes, make informed decisions, and stay ahead.
News & Insights
Newsletter
Legislation Hub
Coverage
Contact
About
© 2025 Foresight. All rights reserved.
SitemapTerms of servicePrivacy policyCookie policy